65 Carmelita St, San Francisco - Sold $5.65M Jan 2026 in Hayes Valley

Sold January 2, 2026 for $5,650,000 · 56 days on market

1 of 92

Listed By Gerald W Guay. DRE# 001168485. Compass. (415) 527-0086

Source: SFAR/San Francisco, MLS # 425085127

65 Carmelita St in San Francisco sold for $5,650,000 on January 2, 2026 — 56 days after coming on the market at $4,398,000. That works out to $1,638 per square foot for a 6-bedroom, 3.5-bath single-family home built in 1899. The 3,450 sq ft house sits in Hayes Valley, which Houseberry scores 3.1/5 overall, 2.8/5 for schools and 3.7/5 for safety — 63rd of 92 neighborhoods in San Francisco — with a typical home price of $1.25M.

Originally developed by renowned builder, Fernando Nelson, this Grand 3 level 6 BR, 4 BA Showpiece Victorian is set on a rare single block cul-de-sac enclave that adjoins vibrant Duboce Park. Exceptionally deep lot with a magical walk-out garden visible from the front entry via 3 rooms of French doors & direct park access behind. Uniquely bright & open integrating modern enhancements while honoring its timeless period detailing. The Main Level enjoys a grand elegant reception foyer that adjoins the stately east-facing double

Date	Event & Source	Price	Change
Jan 02, 2026	Sold SFAR	$5,650,000	+28.5%
Nov 07, 2025	Listed SFAR	$4,398,000

School Name	Type	Grades	Distance	Houseberry School Score
McKinley Elementary	Primary	K-5	0.2 mi	4/5
Everett Middle	Middle	6-8	0.5 mi	2/5

Click links for school listing

info at GreatSchools.org

Houseberry School Score Data

from CA Dept. of Education

Houseberry recommends using these scores as only a starting point, and conducting your own investigation into what schools fit best for your preferences. School boundaries are not guaranteed and may change. It is important to contact the appropriate school district to confirm enrollment eligibility before making any decision to move to a neighborhood.

Near Good Merchants
5.0
Public Spaces
3
Curb Appeal
3

Overall Amenities score: 3.4

1 other sale recorded on Carmelita St since September 2025

The sale on Carmelita St

Address	Sold	Price	Per sq ft
50 Carmelita St	Jun 2026	$7.3M	$1,894

This home's $1,638 per square foot ranks 2nd of the 2 sales on Carmelita St that record one, including this sale.

What neighborhood is 65 Carmelita St in?

65 Carmelita St sits in Hayes Valley, San Francisco. Houseberry ranks Hayes Valley 63rd of the 92 neighborhoods we score in San Francisco.

What schools serve 65 Carmelita St?

Houseberry holds attendance boundaries covering 65 Carmelita St for McKinley Elementary (elementary school, K-5) 0.2 mi away and Everett Middle (middle school, 6-8) 0.5 mi away. We hold no high school boundary for this address, which does not mean there is no high school nearby.

How much did 65 Carmelita St sell for?

65 Carmelita St closed at $5,650,000 on January 2, 2026. It had been asking $4,398,000.

How long was 65 Carmelita St on the market?

65 Carmelita St was on the market for 56 days — listed on November 7, 2025, sale closed on January 2, 2026.

What is the price per square foot at 65 Carmelita St?

65 Carmelita St works out to $1,638 per square foot, from the $5,650,000 sale price across 3,450 square feet.

Is Hayes Valley a good place to live?

Houseberry scores Hayes Valley 3.1 out of 5 overall, with 2.8 for schools and 3.7 for safety, each on the same five-point scale.

See the full Hayes Valley profile