Neighborhood Factors

Market Conditions

  • Neighborhood Factors
    Price
    $1.14M
  • Neighborhood Factors
    Value
    -
  • Neighborhood Factors
    Appreciation
    -4%

Penitencia at a Glance

Penitencia is ranked #63 of 112 neighborhoods in San Jose with an overall score of 3.2/5. Its standout factors are safety (3.7/5, 60th of 112 in San Jose) and public spaces (3.5/5), at a typical home price of $1.14M. The trade-offs are schools (3.1/5) and nearby merchants (3.2/5), though prices run about 22% below the San Jose typical home price.

Penitencia Reviews & Questions

Neighborhood Review
Key Words: Penitencia Creek Park, Creek Trail, Foothill Border

In San Jose, Penitencia takes its name from the creek that gives it its best feature: the Penitencia Creek corridor and its trail run through the neighborhood, and Penitencia Creek Park sits right inside it, a paved greenway that follows the water toward the foothills. That creek-and-trail spine is a real amenity, and it puts this east-Berryessa pocket a notch above the typical flatland tract for green space and walkability along the water. Homes in Penitencia are older detached single-family houses, on streets that back onto or lead to the creek greenway. The hills rise close on the east side, which gives the afternoons a green backdrop most flatland tracts don't get. Yards are a workable size, and the creek side of the neighborhood feels more open than the blocks near the main roads. Alum Rock Park is a quick drive up the canyon road, with miles of trails winding through the canyon past creekside picnic spots and steep ridgeline climbs. Between it and the creek trail, a run or bike ride here can stay off busy streets for a long stretch. For dinner, The Drying Shed on Toyon Avenue is a family-run steakhouse known for prime rib. Over on McKee Road, Antipasto's by DeRose sells house-made ravioli, deli meats and a deep beer selection. Along Berryessa Road near the flea market, Claw Shack is the seafood boil stop, and B Cafe beside it handles coffee and fruit tea on the way home. The San Jose Flea Market on Berryessa Road runs Friday through Sunday, and its long produce row works as a weekend farmers market, an easy place to stock up on fruit and vegetables for the week. VTA's Orange Line stops on Capitol Avenue near the creek, and the Berryessa BART station is a few minutes away to the west. The honest tradeoffs are that district seam, which means school-district and identity lines get mixed near the southern edge, and the general car-dependence of the area. But for a buyer who wants a creek trail and a park essentially at the doorstep, on the greener eastern edge of Berryessa, Penitencia offers more nature than most of the north side, with the foothills as a bonus backdrop.

See City Review for: San Jose

Top Neighborhoods in San Jose, CA

1st
Graystone, San Jose
Graystone, San Jose, CA
Overall Score : 4.3
In San Jose, Graystone is Almaden at its most settled: a hillside grid of split-... See Full Page
2nd
Calabazas North, San Jose
Calabazas North, San Jose, CA
Overall Score : 4.2
In San Jose, Calabazas North is a westside neighborhood built around its park an... See Full Page
3rd
Cambrian, San Jose
Cambrian, San Jose, CA
Overall Score : 4.2
Cambrian is one of those San Jose names that means more than a set of streets. I... See Full Page

Penitencia Amenities

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Near good merchants

    3.2

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Public Spaces

    3.5

  • Neighborhood Amenities
    Curb Appeal

    3.3

Overall Amenities score: 3.3

Penitencia Weather

80%
of possible sunshine
Of all the daylight this spot gets in a year, 80% arrives as sunshine - clouds and fog block the rest.
Penitencia ranks 38th of 112 for sunshine in San Jose, and it out-suns just over half of the Bay Area. Its warmest month is August, averaging 81° highs, and it gets about 15 inches of rain a year.
Average daily high and low temperature
85°70°55°40°JFMAMJJASONDAug 81°
Avg highAvg low
Rank in San Jose
38th of 112
Across the Bay Area
62nd percentile
Rain per year
15 in
Warmest month
Aug 81° avg high
Summer day
56° → 81°F
Winter day
42° → 60°F
Sunshine and temperature figures are 30-year climate averages for this neighborhood's location.

Penitencia Photos

Schools Serving Penitencia

School NameTypeGradesHouseberry School Score
Ben Painter Elementary PrimaryK-8
Toyon Elementary PrimaryK-5
Summerdale Elementary PrimaryK-5
William Sheppard Middle Middle6-8
Piedmont Middle Middle6-8
Independence High High9-12
James Lick High High9-12

Click links for school listing

info at GreatSchools.org

Houseberry School Score Data

from CA Dept. of Education

Houseberry recommends using these scores as only a starting point, and conducting your own investigation into what schools fit best for your preferences. School boundaries are not guaranteed and may change. It is important to contact the appropriate school district to confirm enrollment eligibility before making any decision to move to a neighborhood.

Penitencia Home Prices

Penitencia FAQs

10 answers

Is Penitencia a good place to live?

Penitencia ranks 63rd of 112 neighborhoods in San Jose with an overall Houseberry score of 3.2 out of 5. Its strongest factors are safety (3.7/5) and public spaces (3.5/5). The trade-offs are schools (3.1/5) and nearby merchants (3.2/5).

Is Penitencia safe?

Penitencia, San Jose scores 3.7 out of 5 on Houseberry's Safety Score, ranking 60th of 112 neighborhoods in San Jose.

What do homes in Penitencia cost?

The typical home price in Penitencia, San Jose is $1.14M, compared with $1.47M for San Jose as a whole.

Are home prices in Penitencia rising or falling?

The typical home price in Penitencia, San Jose is down about 3.7% over the past 12 months, at $1.14M. The full 12-month history is charted in the Typical Home Price section on this page.

Which schools serve Penitencia?

Schools serving Penitencia, San Jose include Ben Painter Elementary (1.8/5), Toyon Elementary (2.4/5), Summerdale Elementary (3.5/5), William Sheppard Middle (2.3/5) and Piedmont Middle (3.4/5). 2 more schools are listed in the Schools section on this page.

What is the weather like in Penitencia?

Penitencia, San Jose receives 80% of its possible sunshine, 38th of 112 in San Jose. Summer days run 56° to 81°F and winter days 42° to 60°F, August is the warmest month and rainfall averages about 15 inches a year.

Is Penitencia walkable to shops and restaurants?

Penitencia, San Jose scores 3.2 out of 5 for nearby merchants and 3.5 out of 5 for public spaces. Its overall amenities score is 3.3 out of 5, 44th of 112 in San Jose.

What is Penitencia known for?

Penitencia, San Jose is associated with Penitencia Creek Park, Creek Trail and Foothill Border.

How does Penitencia compare to other San Jose neighborhoods?

Penitencia ranks 63rd of 112 neighborhoods in San Jose. It ranks 60th of 112 in San Jose for safety (3.7/5) and scores lowest on schools (3.1/5). The highest-ranked neighborhoods in San Jose are Graystone and Calabazas North.

What are the downsides of living in Penitencia?

Penitencia, San Jose scores lowest on schools (3.1/5) and nearby merchants (3.2/5).

Follow this neighborhood for updates
Penitencia Photos
Top Neighborhoods in San Jose, CA
1st
Graystone, San Jose
Graystone, San Jose, CA
Overall Score : 4.3
In San Jose, Graystone is Almaden at its most settled: a hillside grid of split-... See Full Page
2nd
Calabazas North, San Jose
Calabazas North, San Jose, CA
Overall Score : 4.2
In San Jose, Calabazas North is a westside neighborhood built around its park an... See Full Page
3rd
Cambrian, San Jose
Cambrian, San Jose, CA
Overall Score : 4.2
Cambrian is one of those San Jose names that means more than a set of streets. I... See Full Page

Penitencia Map

Loading map...

View Full Map

Contact Houseberry's 2026 Agent Pick for Penitencia
Follow this neighborhood for updates